January 28, 2023

Antibody test type and timing key in gauging Covid-19 immunity, United States News & Top Stories

NEW YORK (NYTIMES) – Now that tens of millions of Americans are vaccinated against the coronavirus, many are wondering: Do I have enough antibodies to keep me safe?

For a vast majority of people, the answer is yes. That has not stopped hordes from stampeding to the local doc-in-a-box for antibody testing. But to get a reliable answer from testing, vaccinated people have to get a specific kind of test, and at the right time.

Take the test too soon or rely on one that looks for the wrong antibodies – all too easy to do, given the befuddling array of tests now available – and you may believe yourself to still be vulnerable when you are not.

Actually, scientists would prefer that the average vaccinated person not get antibody testing at all, on the grounds that it is unnecessary. In clinical trials, the vaccines authorised in the United States provoked a strong antibody response in virtually all of the participants.

“Most people shouldn’t even be worrying about this,” said Dr Akiko Iwasaki, an immunologist at Yale University.

But antibody tests can be crucial for people with weak immune systems or those who take certain medications – a broad category encompassing millions of people who are recipients of organ donations, have certain blood cancers or take steroids or other drugs that suppress the immune system.

Mounting evidence suggests that a significant proportion of these people do not produce a sufficient antibody response after vaccination.

If you must get tested or just want to, it is essential to get the right kind of test.

“I feel a little bit hesitant to recommend everybody getting tested, because unless they really understood what the test is doing, people might get this wrong sense of not having developed any antibodies,” Dr Iwasaki said.

Early in the pandemic, many commercial tests were designed to look for antibodies to a coronavirus protein called the nucleocapsid, or just N, because after infection, those antibodies were plentiful in the blood.

But these antibodies are not as powerful as those required to prevent virus infection, nor do they last as long. More importantly, antibodies to the N protein are not produced by the vaccines authorised in the United States; instead, those vaccines provoke antibodies to another protein sitting on the surface of the virus, called the spike.

If people who were never infected are vaccinated and then are tested for antibodies to the N protein instead of the spike, they may be in for a rude shock.

Mr David Lat, a 46-year-old legal writer in New York City, was hospitalised for Covid-19 for three weeks in March 2020, and he chronicled most of his illness and recovery on Twitter.

Over the next year, Mr Lat was tested for antibodies numerous times – when he went to his pulmonologist or cardiologist for follow-ups, for example, or to donate plasma. His antibody levels were high in June 2020 but steadily fell over the following months.

The decline “didn’t worry me,” Mr Lat recalled recently. “I had been told to expect that they would naturally wane, but I was just happy that I was still positive.”


Mr David Lat was hospitalised for Covid-19 for three weeks in March 2020. PHOTO: DAVID LAT

Mr Lat was fully vaccinated by March 22 of this year. But an antibody test April 21, ordered by his cardiologist, was barely positive. Mr Lat was stunned. “I would have thought a month after being immunised, I would have antibodies through the roof,” he said.

Mr Lat turned to Twitter for an explanation.

Dr Florian Krammer, an immunologist at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai in New York City, responded, asking Mr Lat which test had been used. “That’s when I looked at the fine print on the test,” Mr Lat said. He realised it was a test for antibodies to the N protein, not to the spike.

“It seems that by default, they just give you the nucleocapsid one,” Mr Lat said. “I never thought to ask for a different one.”

In May, the Food and Drug Administration recommended against the use of antibody tests for assessing immunity – a decision that has drawn criticism from some scientists – and provided only bare-bones information about testing to health care providers.

Many doctors are still unaware of the differences between antibody tests or the fact that the tests measure just one form of immunity to the virus.

Rapid tests that are commonly available deliver a yes-no result and may miss low levels of antibodies. A certain type of lab test, called an Elisa test, may offer a semiquantitative estimate of antibodies to the spike protein.

It is also important to wait to be tested at least two weeks after the second shot of the Pfizer-BioNTech or Moderna vaccines, when antibody levels will have risen enough to be detectable. For some people receiving the Johnson & Johnson vaccine, that period may be as long as four weeks.

“It’s the timing and the antigen and the sensitivity of the assay – these are going to be very important,” Dr Iwasaki said.

In November, the World Health Organisation set standards for antibody testing, allowing for comparison of different tests.

“There’s a lot of good tests out there now,” Dr Krammer said. “Little by little, all these manufacturers, all these places that run them are adapting to international units.”

Antibodies are just one aspect of immunity, noted Dr Dorry Segev, a transplant surgeon and researcher at Johns Hopkins University. “There’s a lot happening under the surface that antibody tests are not directly measuring,” Dr Segev said.

The body also maintains so-called cellular immunity, a complex network of defenders that also responds to invaders.

Still, for someone who is vaccinated but immuno-compromised, it may be helpful to know that protection against the virus is not what it should be, he said. For example, a transplant patient with poor antibody levels might be able to use test results to convince an employer that he or she should continue to work remotely.

Mr Lat has not sought another test. Just learning that the vaccine most likely has given him a fresh increase of antibodies, despite his test results, was reassurance enough. “I trust that the vaccines work,” he said.

in World
Related Posts

Miami building collapse: Hopes dim as fire hinders rescue efforts, United States News & Top Stories

June 26, 2021

June 26, 2021

SURFSIDE, FLORIDA (REUTERS) – The search for more than 150 missing residents of a Florida building that collapsed two days...

Ecuador confirms Galapagos tortoise is from species thought extinct, World News & Top Stories

May 26, 2021

May 26, 2021

QUITO (AFP) – Officials in Ecuador said on Tuesday (May 25) that genetic tests had confirmed that a turtle found...

Jill Biden will be on the cover of Vogue, United States News & Top Stories

June 29, 2021

June 29, 2021

NEW YORK (NYTIMES) – The White House appears to be back in Vogue’s good graces. Jill Biden, the First Lady,...

In Memorial Day speech, Biden defends ‘imperfect’ democracy, United States News & Top Stories

May 31, 2021

May 31, 2021

ARLINGTON (REUTERS) – US President Joe Biden used his Memorial Day speech on Monday (May 31) to defend America’s “imperfect”...

Defiant Belarus leader accuses West of waging ‘hybrid war’, Europe News & Top Stories

May 26, 2021

May 26, 2021

MOSCOW (REUTERS) – Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko said on Wednesday (May 26) that a journalist pulled off a plane that...

Mystery stones spark diamond rush in poor South African region, World News & Top Stories

June 16, 2021

June 16, 2021

KWAHLATHI (AFP) – Single mother Lihle Magudulela spat out a mouthful of dirt as she sucked on a stone dug...

US Supreme Court says over 250 patent judges were improperly appointed, United States News & Top Stories

June 22, 2021

June 22, 2021

WASHINGTON (NYTIMES) – The US Supreme Court ruled on Monday (June 21) that more than 250 administrative judges who hear...

US vows ‘all in’ approach for domestic climate policy, in line with call to others to cut emissions, United States News & Top Stories

May 23, 2021

May 23, 2021

SINGAPORE -The United States is “all in” when it comes to climate change, and is working to ensure that its...

Belarus teenager investigated over protests kills himself, rights group says, Europe News & Top Stories

May 26, 2021

May 26, 2021

MINSK (REUTERS) – A Belarusian teenager who was being investigated for taking part in anti-government protests last year has taken...

Greater push in US to vaccinate younger adults as Covid-19 Delta strain spread gains speed, United States News & Top Stories

June 23, 2021

June 23, 2021

WASHINGTON – The United States is making a push to inoculate more younger adults, amid concerns that demand for jabs...

Texas says it will build US border wall with Mexico, United States News & Top Stories

June 11, 2021

June 11, 2021

McALLEN, TEXAS (NYTIMES) – Governor Greg Abbott of Texas said Thursday (June 10) that the state would build a border...

Pressure builds on UK’s Boris Johnson to fire health secretary, Europe News & Top Stories

June 26, 2021

June 26, 2021

LONDON (REUTERS) – British Prime Minister Boris Johnson was under mounting pressure on Saturday (June 26) to fire his health...

Covid-19 home test kits becoming more widespread in the US but tests are not perfect, United States News & Top Stories

June 3, 2021

June 3, 2021

WASHINGTON – Home Covid19 test kits are proliferating in the United States, with several available online, and some available over the...

California already in throes of drought as summer looms, United States News & Top Stories

May 30, 2021

May 30, 2021

OROVILLE, UNITED STATES (AFP) – Summer has not even begun and Lake Oroville, the second-largest reservoir in California that provides...

Germany knife attack victims were all women, Europe News & Top Stories

June 26, 2021

June 26, 2021

WUERZBURG, GERMANY (REUTERS) – Authorities in Germany were investigating on Saturday (June 26) what prompted a man to go on...