December 6, 2021

Apple’s Tim Cook Faces Pointed Questions From Judge on App Store Competition

Apple Inc.

AAPL -1.48%

Chief Executive

Tim Cook

faced tough questions from the federal judge who will decide whether the iPhone maker operates an improper monopoly, including about the competitiveness of its App Store payment system.

Mr. Cook spent about four hours Friday on the witness stand in an Oakland, Calif., court trying to rebut claims by “Fortnite” videogame creator Epic Games Inc. that Apple unfairly prohibits competing app stores on the iPhone and forces in-app purchases for digital payments through its own system that takes as much as a 30% cut.

He argued that Apple’s prohibition of rival app stores on the iPhone and its insistence on reviewing all apps sold ensures the security of users. He also pushed back against the Epic lawyer’s attempts to show the company was motivated by profit considerations.

As Mr. Cook’s time on the public witness stand neared an end, U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers interjected, noting that game developers seemed to be generating a disproportionate amount of money for Apple compared with the technology the iPhone maker was providing in turn.

Tim Cook in the federal complex in Oakland, Calif., on Friday.


Noah Berger/Associated Press

She said Apple’s in-app payment system didn’t face competition and zeroed in on why Apple prohibits developers from alerting users in their apps to cheaper options for in-app purchases outside of Apple’s system—an issue that has arisen several times during the trial.

“I understand this notion that somehow Apple brings the customer to the gamers, the users, but after that first time, after that first interaction…the developers are keeping their customers, Apple is just profiting off that,” she said.

Mr. Cook disagreed, arguing that the many free apps available on the App Store attract customers to the potential benefit of game developers, and defended Apple’s right to choose a business model that relies on commissions from apps and in-app purchases.

“If we allowed people to link out like that we would in essence give up our total return on” intellectual property, Mr. Cook said.

‘We’re not thinking about the money at all, we’re thinking about the user.’

— Tim Cook, in court testimony

Unlike in a jury trial, Judge Gonzalez Rogers will decide the case, which is scheduled to end Monday. Both sides have been closely watching her statements and questions during the past three weeks of the trial to gauge how she is leaning; she had previously asked about the idea of allowing developers to notify their users of a cheaper alternative to Apple’s payment system.

Longtime court observers caution against reading too much into any judge’s statements during a proceeding. Judge Gonzalez Rogers’s questions came after Mr. Cook had tried to spend much of his time emphasizing that user security motivates Apple.

“We’re not thinking about the money at all, we’re thinking about the user,” he said.

Mr. Cook began testifying around 8:15 a.m. local time by discussing Apple’s commitment to security and privacy—a familiar theme for the CEO—and his belief that third-party developers with their own app stores aren’t motivated to match the level of user protection that Apple provides with its App Store.

He noted that Apple reviews about 100,000 apps a week and rejects about 40,000 for various reasons.


Does Apple unfairly restrict competition in the mobile-app marketplace? Why, or why not? Join the conversation below.

“You can imagine if you turned the review off how long that it would take the App Store to just become a toxic kind of mess,” Mr. Cook said. “It would be terrible for the user, but it also would be terrible for the developer because the developer depends on the store being a safe and trusted place where customers want to come and feel good about transacting.”

Apple’s case that it isn’t a monopoly has relied on citing Android phones, personal computers and videogame consoles as additional ways for Epic to distribute its “Fortnite’’ game, and underscoring that other platforms collect a similar commission.

Mr. Cook said that Apple faced “fierce” competition from

Alphabet Inc.’s


Samsung Electronics Co.

and others and emphasized how much value his company’s investment in the app economy has created for developers—an assertion fitting claims from Apple’s lawyers that the company’s fees are fair.

“It’s been an economic miracle,” he said.

“What is the problem with allowing users to have choice—especially in gaming content—to find, to having cheaper options?” Judge Gonzalez Rogers asked Mr. Cook.

“I think they have a choice today,” he responded. “They have a choice between many different Android models of a smartphone or an iPhone, and that iPhone has a certain set of principles behind it in safety, security and privacy.”

Mr. Cook’s testimony will be scrutinized well beyond the courtroom as Apple faces increasing threats from lawmakers and regulators around the world examining the power it has over third-party software developers.

Approaching his 10th anniversary as CEO, Mr. Cook is pursuing a strategy for Apple that involves expanding its digital offerings to offset any slowdown in iPhone sales.

In total Mr. Cook testified about four hours, including some time behind closed doors for business confidentiality. He faced questions from Epic’s lawyer of a type that he rarely gets each quarter from Wall Street analysts, including about Apple’s removal of apps for the Chinese government and details of the deal making Google the default search engine on the iPhone.

During the cross-examination, Epic lawyer

Gary Bornstein

tried to pin down Mr. Cook down on whether company calculates the profit margin of its App Store in a bid to illustrate that the company is making outsize profits from developers.

Mr. Cook insisted Apple doesn’t calculate such things and avoided most discussion about profitability. Asked if Apple’s multibillion-dollar deal for Google to be the default search engine on iPhones, he insisted: “It’s still in the best interest of the user.”

“Sir, it’s a very lucrative arrangement for Apple,” Mr. Bornstein said. “Am I right about that?”

Said Mr. Cook: “They pay us money.”

Mr. Bornstein turned to what he called public information that the government has said Google paid Apple upward of $10 billion. In October, the Justice Department filed an antitrust lawsuit against Google that, in part, claimed the search engine was paying between $8 billion and $12 billion annually for the arrangement. Apple wasn’t accused of wrongdoing in that case.

“I don’t remember the exact number,” Mr. Cook responded. Asked if it was upward of $10 billion, Mr. Cook said he didn’t know.

Throughout the trial, both sides focused on Apple’s motivation last fall for lowering the commissions it collects to 15% from 30% on apps generating no more than $1 million in revenue. Mr. Cook said it was prompted by concerns of small businesses amid the Covid-19 pandemic while conceding litigation concerns played some role. The judge said it seemed to stem from the pressure Apple was feeling from investigations and litigation and not competition.

Mr. Cook’s defense of the company’s in-app payment system revolved around the idea that it helps Apple bill developers. Without it, he said, “It would be a mess.”

Apple’s stock-market value hit a new record this year, but its longstanding disputes with app developers are bubbling over into public view. WSJ explains why high-profile companies like Epic Games, Spotify and Tinder are at odds with App Store rules. Video/illustration: Jaden Urbi/WSJ

His testimony put Mr. Cook in the same courtroom as rival

Tim Sweeney,

the co-founder and CEO of Epic, who has attended the trial each day

Mr. Sweeney took the witness stand during the trial’s first week, describing how Epic violated Apple’s app-store rules in order to show the power the iPhone maker wields. “Apple was making more profit from selling developer apps in the App Store than developers,” Mr. Sweeney testified on the trial’s opening day.

Epic filed its lawsuit against Apple in August after the iPhone maker kicked “Fortnite” out of the App Store for violating its rules. Epic’s team had created an in-app payment system aimed at circumventing Apple’s and sneaked it into “Fortnite” that month.

On the stand Friday, Mr. Cook said the return of “Fortnite” to the App Store would benefit the user—if Epic followed Apple’s rules. “The user is caught between two companies,” he said. “It’s not the right thing to do with the user.”

Write to Tim Higgins at

Corrections & Amplifications
Nina Riggio of Bloomberg News is credited for the photo of Tim Cook arriving at court on Friday. An earlier version of this article incorrectly carried a credit for David Paul Morris of Bloomberg News. (Corrected on May 21.)

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

in Tech
Related Posts

Elon Musk’s Starlink Could Get Boost From German Subsidies

June 1, 2021

June 1, 2021

BERLIN—Germany could become the first large nation to subsidize the use of consumer satellite internet services such as that offered...

You’re Going Back to the Office. Here Is What Your Day Might Look Like.

May 29, 2021

May 29, 2021

It’s 6 a.m., Monday, somewhere in America, and Jane Q. Office Worker’s alarm goes off. She’s tempted to hit the...

Netflix Strikes Deal With Filmmaker Steven Spielberg

June 21, 2021

June 21, 2021

Under the terms of the deal, announced Monday by Netflix and Mr. Spielberg’s Amblin Partners, the studio will make multiple...

Can America’s Solar Power Industry Compete with China’s? One Firm Tries

June 21, 2021

June 21, 2021

WALBRIDGE, Ohio—Solar panels are part of any formula for fighting climate change, yet the U.S. makes few of them, since...

Apple Subpoenas From DOJ Prompt Internal Review, Calls for William Barr, Jeff Sessions to Testify

June 11, 2021

June 11, 2021

WASHINGTON—The Justice Department’s internal watchdog and Senate Democrats vowed to investigate the Trump administration’s secret seizure of communication records of...

Quanergy to Go Public Through SPAC Deal

June 22, 2021

June 22, 2021

Quanergy Systems Inc., a provider of lidar sensors and 3-D perception software, is going public through a combination with a...

Glitch Unmasks Role of Networks Making Websites Faster

June 9, 2021

June 9, 2021

The use of remote networks to make websites run faster can also leave the sites vulnerable to outages, such as...

Lordstown Clarifies That Vehicle Purchase Agreements Aren’t Binding Orders

June 17, 2021

June 17, 2021

Lordstown Motors Corp. RIDE 3.30% said in a securities filing that although it has struck vehicle-purchase agreements with fleet-management companies,...

Amazon Founder Jeff Bezos to Be on Blue Origin’s First Human Space Flight

June 7, 2021

June 7, 2021

Jeff Bezos plans to travel to space next month as one of the first passengers carried by Blue Origin, the...

Former WeWork Chief’s Gargantuan Exit Package Gets New Sweetener

May 27, 2021

May 27, 2021

Nearly two years ago, SoftBank Group Corp. 9984 -2.20% sought to part ways with WeWork co-founder Adam Neumann when it...

Gene Therapy, High-Tech Goggles Restore Some Vision to Blind People

May 24, 2021

May 24, 2021

Scientists are making dramatic strides toward a goal that once seemed almost unimaginable: Restoring limited vision to people affected by...

Verizon Offers Low-Cost Service Commitment to Seal TracFone Deal

July 1, 2021

July 1, 2021

Verizon Communications Inc. told federal regulators it would keep supporting low-cost wireless service for three years if it is allowed...

Pinterest's Use of AI Drives Growth

May 22, 2021

May 22, 2021

Using neural networks, the site is able to find images—and ads—that will catch the consumer’s eye.

Microsoft Launches Windows 11 in a Reboot for the App-Economy Age

June 24, 2021

June 24, 2021

Microsoft Corp. MSFT 0.39% on Thursday unveiled an overhaul of its Windows operating system designed to update the software that...

Intel Delays New Chip in First Setback for CEO Gelsinger’s Turnaround Effort

June 29, 2021

June 29, 2021

Chip maker Intel Corp. is delaying production of one of its newest chips to improve performance, the first significant product...