July 2, 2022

Johnson & Johnson Asks High Court to Void $2 Billion Talc Verdict | Voice of America

WASHINGTON – Johnson & Johnson is asking for Supreme Court review of a $2 billion verdict in favor of women who claim they developed ovarian cancer from using the company’s talc products. 

In this image from video, Kenneth Starr, an attorney for President Donald Trump, speaks during Trump's impeachment trial in the Senate at the Capitol in Washington, Jan. 27, 2020.
FILE – In this image from video, Kenneth Starr speaks during former President DonaldTrump’s impeachment trial in the Senate at the Capitol in Washington, January 27, 2020.

The case features an array of high-profile attorneys, some in unusual alliances, including former independent counsel Kenneth Starr, who is representing the women who sued Johnson & Johnson. The nation’s largest business groups are backing the company, and a justice’s father also makes an appearance because of his long association with the trade group for cosmetics and personal care products. 

The court could say as soon as Tuesday whether it will get involved. 

At the root, Johnson & Johnson argues that the company didn’t get a fair shake in a trial in state court in Missouri that resulted in an initial $4.7 billion verdict in favor of 22 women who used talc products and developed ovarian cancer. 

State appeals court ruling

A state appeals court cut more than half the money out of the verdict and eliminated two of the plaintiffs but otherwise upheld the outcome in a trial in which lawyers for both sides presented dueling expert testimony about whether the company’s talc products contain asbestos and asbestos-laced talc can cause ovarian cancer. 

The jury found for the women on both points, after which Judge Rex M. Burlison wrote that evidence at the trial showed “particularly reprehensible conduct on the part of (the) defendants.” 

The evidence, Burlison wrote, included that the company knew there was asbestos in products aimed at mothers and babies, knew of the potential harm and “misrepresented the safety of these products for decades.” 

Nine of the women have died from ovarian cancer, lawyers for the plaintiffs said. 

Johnson & Johnson denies that its talc products cause cancer, and it called the verdict in the Missouri trial “at odds with decades of independent scientific evaluations confirming Johnson’s Baby Powder is safe, is not contaminated by asbestos and does not cause cancer.” The company also is the maker of one of three COVID-19 vaccines approved for use in the United States. 

Thousands of lawsuits over talc

Health concerns about talcum powders have prompted thousands of U.S. lawsuits by women who claim asbestos in the powder caused their cancer. Talc is a mineral similar in structure to asbestos, which is known to cause cancer, and they are sometimes obtained from the same mines. The cosmetics industry in 1976 agreed to make sure its talc products do not contain detectable amounts of asbestos. 

Last year, a U.S. government-led analysis of 250,000 women found no strong evidence linking baby powder with ovarian cancer in the largest analysis to look at the question, though the study’s lead author called the results “very ambiguous.” 

The findings were called “overall reassuring” in an editorial published with the study in January 2020 in the Journal of the American Medical Association. The study wasn’t definitive, but more conclusive research probably isn’t feasible because a dwindling number of women use powder for personal hygiene, the editorial said. 

Removing product from market

A few months later, the company announced it would stop selling its iconic talc-based Johnson’s Baby Powder in the U.S. and Canada, citing declining demand driven by what it called misinformation about health concerns. 

The disputed link between cancer and talc is not really a part of the high court case. Instead, the company said it should have not been forced to defend itself in one trial against claims by women from 12 states, differing backgrounds and with varying histories of using Johnson & Johnson products containing talc. 

FILE - This April 25, 2018 file photo shows attorney Neal Katyal speaking to members of the media outside the Supreme Court in…
FILE – This April 25, 2018 file photo shows attorney Neal Katyal speaking to members of the media outside the Supreme Court in Washington.

The $1.6 billion in punitive damages is out of line and should be reduced, the company also argued in a brief that was written by Neal Katyal, a Washington lawyer who aligns with progressive causes and also represents corporate clients. Katyal, who was the acting top Supreme Court lawyer for a time in the Obama administration, declined an on-the-record interview. 

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and trade associations for manufacturers, insurers and the pharmaceutical industry are among the business organizations backing Johnson & Johnson’s appeal. 

Tiger Joyce, president of the American Tort Reform Association, pointed to how long it took the trial judge to read the jury its instructions as an indication of how unfair the trial was to Johnson & Johnson.  

“When a defendant is facing a case where it takes over five hours for the judge to read the instructions to the jury, you just have to ask yourself, ‘What are we doing here?” said Joyce, whose group generally backs limits on liability lawsuits.  

Starr said in an interview with The Associated Press that none of Johnson & Johnson’s legal arguments is worth the court’s time.  

“As the jury found, and as every judge to review this six-week trial record has concluded, Johnson & Johnson’s conduct over decades was reprehensible,” Starr said.  

Notable names

In addition to Starr, other members of the women’s legal team are former Attorney General John Ashcroft and Washington lawyers David Frederick and Tom Goldstein, frequent advocates before the Supreme Court. 

Justice Brett Kavanaugh worked for Starr when he investigated the affair between President Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky, which led to Clinton’s impeachment. 

Another name that pops up in some documents in the case is E. Edward Kavanaugh, who was the longtime president of the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Fragrance Association and is the justice’s father. 

Kavanaugh’s group fought efforts to list talc as a carcinogen or attach warning labels to talc products. Kavanaugh is retired, and the group now is called the Personal Care Products Council. 

Ethicists contacted by AP said they haven’t seen anything that would warrant the justice having to step aside from the case.  

Already, one justice almost certainly won’t take part. Justice Samuel Alito reported last year that he owned $15,000 to $50,000 in Johnson & Johnson stock. Federal law prohibits judges from sitting on cases in which they have financial interest. 

 

in U.S.
Related Posts

Britain Delays Plans to Lift COVID-19 Lockdowns | Voice of America

June 14, 2021

June 14, 2021

British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has delayed plans to lift coronavirus restrictions by a month because of the highly contagious...

Military Defends January 6 Response as House Steps Up Probes | Voice of America

June 15, 2021

June 15, 2021

A top Army leader defended the Pentagon’s response to the January 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol, telling a House...

Turkey Pushes for Role in Afghanistan After US Pullout  | Voice of America

June 21, 2021

June 21, 2021

ISTANBUL – Turkey is seeking to play a vital role in Afghanistan following the withdrawal of US forces by offering...

US Military Says Withdrawal From Afghanistan More Than Half Complete  | Voice of America

June 8, 2021

June 8, 2021

WASHINGTON – The U.S. military estimates that it has completed more than half of its withdrawal from Afghanistan, a pace...

Another Devastating Atlantic Hurricane Season Forecast for 2021 | Voice of America

June 1, 2021

June 1, 2021

GENEVA – The World Meteorological Organization (WMO) warns the United States and countries in the Caribbean and Central America to...

Blinken Meets with Pope, Italian Officials | Voice of America

June 28, 2021

June 28, 2021

U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken visited the Vatican on Monday to meet with Pope Francis and other officials with climate change, human rights and...

Hunt is on for Burmese Pythons, Florida Natives’ Archenemy | Voice of America

June 6, 2021

June 6, 2021

MIAMI, FLORIDA – Professional python hunters and amateurs alike have a chance to win prizes in Florida’s annual hunt for...

UN Chief Urges US to Lift Sanctions on Iran | Voice of America

June 30, 2021

June 30, 2021

The U.N. secretary-general has called on the United States to lift its sanctions on Iran and for both countries to...

US Senate Republicans Set to Block Capitol Riot Inquiry Panel | Voice of America

May 27, 2021

May 27, 2021

Republicans in the U.S. Senate are expected Thursday to block legislation calling for the creation of a panel to investigate...

Biden’s $6 Trillion Budget Sidesteps Some Campaign Pledges | Voice of America

June 2, 2021

June 2, 2021

WASHINGTON – When Democrat Joe Biden ran for vice president in 2008, he delivered a speech in which he repeated...

Mobile Vaccination Units Hit Tiny US Towns to Boost COVID Immunity | Voice of America

May 31, 2021

May 31, 2021

FALLON, Nev. — Pick-up truck drivers motor up to a white trailer in a parking lot on Fallon Paiute-Shoshone land...

Biden Urges Cease-fire in Ethiopia’s Tigray, Says Rights Abuses ‘Must End’  | Voice of America

May 27, 2021

May 27, 2021

U.S. President Joe Biden condemned the six-month conflict in Ethiopia’s Tigray region Wednesday, calling for a cease-fire and declaring that...

US Supreme Court Unanimously Rules Against NCAA | Voice of America

June 21, 2021

June 21, 2021

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Monday against the National Collegiate Athletic Association’s limits on education-related benefits that student athletes can...

Kentucky to Allow College Athletes to Earn Off Likeness | Voice of America

June 25, 2021

June 25, 2021

FRANKFORT, KENTUCKY – Kentucky’s governor signed an order Thursday allowing the state’s college athletes — including players on the nationally...

Blinken Heads to Egypt, Jordan on First Middle East Tour | Voice of America

May 26, 2021

May 26, 2021

A day after expressing support for Israel’s security and announcing reconstruction aid for Gaza, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken travels Wednesday...