December 6, 2021

Lina Khan, Critic of Large Tech Firms, to Lead Federal Trade Commission

WASHINGTON—The Senate on Tuesday confirmed Lina Khan for a seat on the Federal Trade Commission, and President Biden tapped her to lead the agency, a post that will allow her to pursue aggressive enforcement of U.S. antitrust and consumer-protection laws.

Ms. Khan, a 32-year-old Columbia University law professor who has been a vocal critic of powerful technology companies, was confirmed on a 69-28 vote. With her confirmation secured, Mr. Biden immediately designated her as FTC chairwoman, a move that caps the ascendancy of a progressive camp that favors far-reaching changes to antitrust enforcement.

Ms. Khan has been the leader of that movement, which believes the current decadeslong approach has done too little to restrain corporate dominance and stop mergers that have eroded competition. She has argued in favor of blocking more mergers, aggressively attacking monopolistic practices and potentially breaking up some of America’s largest companies.

While Democrats across the board have argued that antitrust enforcement has been too lax, they have been split on just how far the pendulum should swing. Some have questioned whether a wholesale philosophical shift is needed. Ms. Khan’s leading FTC role signals which way Mr. Biden is leaning in that debate, a warning shot to Silicon Valley and dominant firms in other industries.

The FTC scrutinizes proposed corporate mergers and an array of business practices to determine whether they illegally suppress competition in the marketplace. The commission also has a broad consumer-protection mission, targeting scams and other types of unfair or deceptive business conduct that harm the public.

Ms. Khan is the youngest FTC chairperson in history. She’ll take the helm from Democratic Commissioner Rebecca Kelly Slaughter, who has been running the FTC on an acting basis.

“Congress created the FTC to safeguard fair competition and protect consumers, workers, and honest businesses from unfair & deceptive practices,” Ms. Khan said on Twitter after her confirmation. “I look forward to upholding this mission with vigor and serving the American public.”

The Senate’s vote was bipartisan, with 21 Republicans voting for Ms. Khan at a time when many in the GOP say the government should do more to rein in dominant tech firms. Still, some Republicans have criticized her approach as too interventionist and potentially burdensome for other industries.

Ms. Khan has reserved her deepest criticisms for dominant tech companies, especially

Amazon.com Inc.,

the subject of a widely read law-review article she wrote while at Yale Law School that argued that antitrust law has failed to restrain the online retailer.

She also served as a key staffer on a House antitrust panel that conducted a 16-month investigation of large online platforms and last year recommended that lawmakers take steps to rein them in.

NetChoice, an industry group with members including

Amazon.com Inc.,

Google and

Facebook Inc.,

said it was “disheartened” by Ms. Khan’s confirmation and questioned whether she could “enforce antitrust laws as they are, not as the commissioner wishes they would be.”

Wayne State University law professor

Stephen Calkins

said the way the White House waited until after Ms. Khan’s confirmation to tap her to chair the FTC was unusual. Normally an administration either nominates an outsider as chairman from the outset or instead designates as chairman someone who already has been serving on the commission, he said.

Ms. Khan’s confirmation for now gives Democrats a 3-2 edge at the FTC, though another Democrat—

Rohit Chopra

—is likely on the way out, because Mr.

Biden

has nominated him to run the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

Mr. Chopra is awaiting a vote by the full Senate for that post, making it possible that the FTC will have only a limited time window to address any pending matters that might potentially divide the commission along partisan lines. It could take several months to get a successor to Mr. Chopra confirmed.

The White House has been slow to nominate a full cast of antitrust enforcers, creating uncertainty about the administration’s approach to enforcing U.S. laws that are designed to promote and protect competition. The president hasn’t yet nominated anyone to run the Justice Department’s antitrust division, which shares authority with the FTC.

Antitrust Enforcement

Related articles, selected by WSJ editors

The FTC’s current commissioners act with consensus on an array of enforcement matters, but at times have split in deep and visible ways, including in last year’s antitrust lawsuit alleging unlawful monopolization by

Facebook Inc.

and a recent controversy over a convenience-store merger involving the 7-Eleven chain.

FTC Democrats have signaled they would like to take a tougher line on mergers and focus more enforcement attention on anticompetitive business conduct, including by issuing first-of-their-kind regulations that would prohibit certain kinds of business practices as unfair methods of competition.

If the FTC decides to push antitrust boundaries in future cases, it will face a federal judiciary that over recent decades has read antitrust law more narrowly. Both the commission and Justice Department have lost high-profile cases in recent years.

Congress is considering whether to make legislative changes to promote more expansive enforcement, but it isn’t clear if lawmakers will find enough consensus to move forward.

The commission for many months has been examining a variety of practices by Amazon. It is also possible the FTC could review the online giant’s proposed acquisition of Hollywood studio MGM.

Ms. Khan has faced questions about whether she would have to recuse herself in an FTC case against large technology companies because of her past work on the House antitrust investigation. She has said she would consult with FTC ethics officials if recusal questions arose.

Write to Brent Kendall at brent.kendall@wsj.com

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

in Tech
Related Posts

Trump’s TikTok, WeChat Actions Targeting China Revoked by Biden

June 9, 2021

June 9, 2021

WASHINGTON—President Biden revoked a Trump -era attempt to ban Chinese-owned apps TikTok and WeChat, substituting Wednesday an executive order mandating...

Best Tech Gifts 2021: Our Favorite Gadgets

November 14, 2021

November 14, 2021

The global chip shortage posed a unique challenge for our annual list of the most gift-worthy tech products—especially when it...

Bitcoin on the Balance Sheet Is an Accounting Headache for Tesla, Others

June 14, 2021

June 14, 2021

Elon Musk’s curious Twitter war with bitcoin is expected to hit Tesla Inc.’s TSLA -0.04% bottom line this quarter. Mr....

Teslas Made in Russia? Elon Musk Says It’s Possible

May 21, 2021

May 21, 2021

MOSCOW— Elon Musk raised the prospect of Russian-made Tesla Inc. TSLA -1.01% cars, saying the company was considering opening a...

SEC Is Running Out of Options to Rein In Elon Musk

June 2, 2021

June 2, 2021

WASHINGTON—The Securities and Exchange Commission has tried for several years to get Elon Musk to behave more like a typical...

Supreme Court Draws Limit to Anti-Hacking Law

June 4, 2021

June 4, 2021

WASHINGTON—The Supreme Court Thursday narrowed the scope of a federal anti-hacking law, ruling that it doesn’t cover individuals who use...

Chinese Surveillance-Gear Maker Hikvision Has Ties to Country’s Military, Report Says

May 25, 2021

May 25, 2021

HONG KONG—The world’s largest maker of surveillance equipment has long-established links to China’s military, including conducting a study with Chinese...

China’s New Power Play: More Control of Tech Companies’ Troves of Data

June 12, 2021

June 12, 2021

Shortly after rising to power in late 2012, Xi Jinping made his first company visit in his new job as...

Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Could Be Unmasked at Florida Trial

November 14, 2021

November 14, 2021

A seemingly run-of-the-mill trial is playing out in Florida: The family of a deceased man is suing his former business...

Ransomware Boom Forces More Companies to Cut Deals With Criminals

May 20, 2021

May 20, 2021

Kurtis Minder got into the ransomware negotiation business by accident early last year. The startup he co-founded, GroupSense Inc., monitors...

Driver-Assistance Crashes Attract Closer U.S. Scrutiny

June 29, 2021

June 29, 2021

Federal regulators are tightening their oversight of car crashes that involve advanced driver-assistance or automated-driving features, a shift that follows...

Colonial Pipeline CEO Tells Why He Paid Hackers a $4.4 Million Ransom

May 19, 2021

May 19, 2021

The operator of the Colonial Pipeline learned it was in trouble at daybreak on May 7, when an employee found...

CyrusOne Nears Deal to Be Sold to a Private Equity Buyer

November 12, 2021

November 12, 2021

CyrusOne Inc. is nearing a deal to be sold to a private-equity buyer that could value the data-center operator at...

Gene Therapy, High-Tech Goggles Restore Some Vision to Blind People

May 24, 2021

May 24, 2021

Scientists are making dramatic strides toward a goal that once seemed almost unimaginable: Restoring limited vision to people affected by...

WeWork’s Adam Neumann to Pay $44 Million for Two Miami Beach Properties

June 17, 2021

June 17, 2021

WeWork founder Adam Neumann is in contract to buy adjacent properties at Miami Beach’s Bal Harbour Yacht Club marina for...