September 27, 2022

Permanent Cap on Delivery-App Fees Proposed for New York City

The New York City Council is considering a legislative package aimed at significantly regulating the food-delivery app industry, including permanently limiting fees that operators like Grubhub and Uber Eats can charge restaurants.

In a bid to help the city’s struggling restaurant industry survive the Covid-19 pandemic, the council last year passed legislation temporarily prohibiting third-party food-delivery services from charging eateries more than 15% per delivery order and more than 5% for marketing and other nondelivery fees.

However, the combined 20% cap is set to expire Aug. 17. It only covers the first 90 days after New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo allowed indoor dining to reopen May 19 at full capacity statewide.

Some small restaurant operators say the app fees typically can run them a combined 30% or more of what they take in on every order.

A new bill sponsored by Councilman Francisco Moya, a Queens Democrat, would make the cap permanent. Violators would face up to $1,000 a day in fines per restaurant, the same penalty covered under the temporary law.

Mr. Moya said a permanent cap is needed because “for far too long, these third-party apps knowingly and willingly took advantage of small businesses.”

Grubhub, which also operates the delivery app Seamless, has long threatened litigation over such action. It has said that its services help businesses grow and that no government should meddle in existing contractual agreements between privately owned eateries and food-delivery services.

Demand for food delivery has soared amid the pandemic, but restaurants are struggling to survive. In a fiercely competitive industry, delivery services are fighting to gain market share while facing increased pressure to lower commission fees and provide more protection to their workers. Video/Photo: Jaden Urbi/WSJ

The company, which says it breaks even on the delivery portion of its business and makes its revenue by marketing restaurants to users on its platform, said it is currently reviewing its legal options in regard to the package of bills.

Grant Klinzman, a spokesman for Grubhub, said a permanent cap would result in “unprecedented, damaging and long-term consequences for locally-owned businesses, delivery workers, diners and the local economy.”

“Fee caps limit how restaurants, and especially small and independent establishments, can effectively market themselves to drive demand, [and] therefore severely limit how many customers and orders we can bring to these restaurants,” he said.

An Uber Eats spokesman declined to comment.

Dozens of other cities across the U.S.—including Los Angeles and Seattle—have created similar temporary caps to assist restaurants during the pandemic, but many are also set to expire as eateries fully reopen.

San Francisco’s board of supervisors on Tuesday approved a permanent 15% cap per order on food-delivery fees, making the city the nation’s first to enact a permanent ceiling. It still requires final approval from San Francisco Mayor London Breed.

Council member Mark Gjonaj has introduced several regulatory bills.


William Alatriste/New York City Council

However, unlike Mr. Moya’s bill for New York City, San Francisco opted not to address capping other lucrative charges like marketing fees.

The California State Assembly passed a bill last month mandating more transparency from food-delivery apps, but not before removing key language that would have placed a permanent 15% statewide cap on delivery fees.


Lorena Gonzalez,

a San Diego Democrat, who was the bill’s sponsor, said in an interview that she plans to introduce another bill next year to create a permanent cap, adding she believes there will be more support once temporary caps in cities throughout California expire.

Until then, Ms. Gonzalez said she plans to closely monitor the permanent-cap plans in New York City and San Francisco for guidance.

Mr. Moya’s bill and three others sponsored by Councilman Mark Gjonaj that also seek to regulate the industry in New York City will be discussed publicly for the first time during a June 30 hearing before the council’s committee on small business.

“My mandate is to ensure a level playing field in the David-versus-Goliath relationship that mom-and-pop eateries have with venture-capital-backed food-delivery platforms,” said Mr. Gjonaj, a Bronx Democrat who chairs the committee.

His bills include legislation prohibiting third-party delivery companies from including eateries on their apps or websites without a written agreement. Another bill would permanently prohibit these services from charging restaurants for phone orders that didn’t result in a transaction during the call.


What are the pros and cons of the New York City Council’s food-delivery regulations? Join the conversation below.

Mr. Gjonaj’s third bill would require the companies to reveal whenever they own a unique telephone number associated with the restaurants they are promoting and list a direct number for these eateries on their websites and apps.


Bill de Blasio

and Council Speaker

Corey Johnson,

both Democrats, are reviewing the bills, according to their spokespersons. They both previously supported the council legislation that created the temporary cap on fees.

Andrew Rigie, executive director of the New York City Hospitality Alliance, which represents restaurant and nightlife establishments, said the legislative package is long overdue, adding he believes “some third-party delivery companies were exploiting restaurants before the pandemic, and they’ve only consolidated power since.”

“We can’t let these billion-dollar corporations exploit our local restaurants— especially as they try to recover from the pandemic,” he said.

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

Related Posts

Move to a New City for Work? No Thanks

June 7, 2021

June 7, 2021

Fewer workers have been moving for new jobs during the pandemic. Will anyone want to when it’s over? The percentage...

Planes Grounded by Covid-19 Largely Avoid the Junkyard—for Now

June 4, 2021

June 4, 2021

SYDNEY—After the coronavirus pandemic grounded air travel, many of the thousands of aircraft that were parked at storage facilities around...

Elon Musk’s Tax Bill on Stock Options Fell Along With Tesla’s Share Price

November 24, 2021

November 24, 2021

Elon Musk already faces a federal tax bill topping $3.5 billion on exercising Tesla Inc. stock options. It would have...

Biden Administration to Suspend Oil Leases in Arctic Refuge

June 1, 2021

June 1, 2021

WASHINGTON—The Biden administration is putting a hold on oil and gas leases in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska,...

Supply Crunch Risks Extending Into 2022, Stoking Inflation

June 20, 2021

June 20, 2021

Supply constraints that have challenged businesses and caused shortages of everything from semiconductors to sweatpants are deepening, adding to pressure...

Google Settles Antitrust Case Over Advertising Practices

June 7, 2021

June 7, 2021

The French competition authority alleged Google’s advertising server gave the company’s online ad auction house an advantage in advertising auctions....

Citigroup, JPMorgan to Resume Campaign Donations

June 4, 2021

June 4, 2021

WASHINGTON—Two major U.S. banks said they will resume campaign donations from their political-action committee, but split on the question about...

GameStop’s Chief Operating Officer Departs

October 29, 2021

October 29, 2021

GameStop Corp.’s chief operating officer, Jenna Owens, has left the company, less than a year after joining. GameStop didn’t give...

Walmart to Sell New Line of Gap-Branded Homegoods

May 26, 2021

May 26, 2021

Walmart Inc. WMT -0.12% and Gap Inc. GPS 4.16% plan to partner on a line of Gap-branded homegoods that will...

Robust Spending Is Likely Propelling Economy to Stronger Growth

May 28, 2021

May 28, 2021

Americans likely extended a spending binge in April as they continued catching up on activities they held off on during...

Boeing Offloads Unclaimed MAX Jets as Air Travel Recovers

June 11, 2021

June 11, 2021

A faster-than-expected recovery in domestic air travel is helping Boeing Co. find new homes for unclaimed 737 MAX jets whose...

Music Publishers Sue Roblox for Letting Game Creators Use Unlicensed Songs

June 9, 2021

June 9, 2021

A group of music publishers representing the songwriters of hits from Ed Sheeran, Ariana Grande and the Rolling Stones is...

DuPont Plans Moves That Would Remake Chemicals Company

November 2, 2021

November 2, 2021

DuPont de Nemours Inc. is planning deals that would remake the famed chemicals company, according to people familiar with the...

Puerto Rico’s Power Distributor Suffered a Cyberattack Hours Before a Devastating Fire

June 11, 2021

June 11, 2021

Puerto Rico’s main power provider suffered a cyberattack shortly before a fire at a substation in San Juan Thursday caused...

Drought’s Toll on U.S. Agriculture Points to Even-Higher Food Prices

July 1, 2021

July 1, 2021

The Southwest is suffering through one of its worst droughts on record amid a critical reduction in the amount of...