July 4, 2022

PHAC head doubles down, withholds docs on fired scientists as House reprimand looms – National

The head of the Public Health Agency of Canada is showing no sign he’s willing to release unredacted documents about the firing of two scientists at the country’s highest security laboratory — despite the prospect of being publicly shamed in the House of Commons for his refusal to produce the information.

PHAC president Iain Stewart told the Commons health committee Friday that he is bound by law to protect national security and privacy rights.

And he said nothing in a House order demanding that he produce the documents relieves him of that obligation.

“I am a career public servant and, as a career public servant, I am required to follow the law,” Stewart told the committee.

Read more:
PHAC found in contempt after withholding documents on fired Chinese scientists

Story continues below advertisement

He said he’s following the advice he’s received from “legal and security experts” in the Justice Department.

“As accountable head of the Public Health Agency, I am the person … who provides the documents and, hence, I find myself in this extraordinary situation in this 27th year of my career. But it’s not the exercise of my choice that’s putting me here, it’s the obligations of my job.”

Opposition parties joined forces earlier this week to pass a motion finding PHAC in contempt of Parliament and summoning Stewart to appear Monday before the bar of the Commons to be reprimanded by the Speaker and to produce the documents.

Stewart said he looks forward to Monday “as it comes.” He refused to say specifically whether he’d hand over the documents at that time but his testimony under persistent opposition questioning Friday suggested he will not.


Click to play video: 'Tories demand release of Winnipeg lab documents amid questions on employees’ Chinese military connection'







Tories demand release of Winnipeg lab documents amid questions on employees’ Chinese military connection


Tories demand release of Winnipeg lab documents amid questions on employees’ Chinese military connection – Jun 1, 2021

Calling someone to the bar of the House is a rarely used procedure to essentially publicly shame a person deemed to have committed “an offence against the dignity or authority of Parliament,” according to House of Commons Procedure and Practice.

Story continues below advertisement

Since 1913, it has not been used against a private citizen, although it has been used twice, in 1991 and 2002, to discipline MPs who had grabbed the ceremonial mace during heated Commons proceedings.

Stewart has twice refused an order from the Canada-China relations committee to produce unredacted documents that would shed light on why scientists Xiangguo Qiu and her husband, Keding Cheng, were escorted out of Winnipeg’s National Microbiology Laboratory in July 2019 and subsequently fired last January.

He has similarly refused to comply with a Commons motion passed by opposition parties earlier this month to turn over all unredacted documents to the parliamentary law clerk, who would confidentially review them and redact anything he felt would compromise national security or the ongoing police investigation.

That motion specified that the Canada-China relations committee, after consulting with the law clerk, could choose to make public any redacted material.

PHAC has instead turned over the unredacted documents to the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians, whose members have top security clearance and are bound to secrecy.

Read more:
The House of Commons is about to use a power it hasn’t invoked on non-MPs in more than a century

Commons Speaker Anthony Rota ruled Wednesday that giving the documents to that body is not sufficient to comply with the House order since it is not a committee of Parliament. He further ruled that the Commons and its standing committees have unfettered power to order the production of unredacted documents, no matter how sensitive, and to determine how they’re to be handled.

Story continues below advertisement

Opposition members of the health committee repeatedly referred to that ruling Friday, demanding Stewart recognize that Parliament is supreme and to finally comply with the order to turn over the documents.

“Nothing in the motions heretofore have made me not legally liable for the choice I’m being asked to make,” Stewart told them.

He asked in turn if MPs believe the House order and Speaker’s ruling provide him with “immunity” for breaking the Privacy Act and the Security of Information Act.

“Is that what this is about, Mr. Stewart? Your own hide?” shot back NDP health critic Don Davies.

“As a public servant, I’m bound by law and I have to follow the law,” Stewart replied.


Click to play video: 'Winnipeg’s National Microbiology Laboratory is ground zero in Canada’s fight against COVID-19'







Winnipeg’s National Microbiology Laboratory is ground zero in Canada’s fight against COVID-19


Winnipeg’s National Microbiology Laboratory is ground zero in Canada’s fight against COVID-19 – Mar 23, 2020

Conservative health critic Michelle Rempel Garner pointed out that an order of the House of Commons is also lawful. Indeed, the parliamentary law clerk has advised the committee that a House order supercedes other statutes passed by Parliament.

Story continues below advertisement

However, Liberal MP Jennifer O’Connell argued that releasing the documents to parliamentarians without the proper security clearance could allow Russia, China and other “bad actors” to gain access to sensitive information.

Stewart agreed that “materials related to a level four lab are of interest to many parties.” Indeed, he said the “cumulative effect” of the little unredacted material PHAC has released so far about scientists’ firing “does, in and of itself, begin to create security concerns for the intelligence community.”

The impact of releasing unredacted the other classified documents “would be even more profound,” Stewart said.

Members of the Canada-China relations committee to whom he was ordered to release the documents do not have security clearance and don’t have the ability to handle classified documents or even to have secure communications about them, he added.

“It’s done over the worldwide web,” he said.

View link »





© 2021 The Canadian Press

Related Posts

Sexual misconduct in Canada’s military remains as ‘rampant’ in 2021 as in 2015: report – National

June 1, 2021

June 1, 2021

Sexual misconduct in the Canadian Forces remains as “rampant” and “destructive” in 2021 as it was back in 2015...

N.S. First Nation further delays lobster fishing, saying it risks losing traps

June 2, 2021

June 2, 2021

By Michael Tutton The Canadian Press Posted June 2, 2021 2:14 pm Smaller font ...

House of Commons issues first formal rebuke to non-MP in nearly 110 years over Winnipeg lab docs – National

June 21, 2021

June 21, 2021

The president of the Public Health Agency of Canada is now the first non-MP in more than a 100...

Ottawa mum on whether Trudeau joining Biden’s G7 push on Northern Ireland peace – National

June 10, 2021

June 10, 2021

The government isn’t saying whether Prime Minister Justin Trudeau will join U.S. President Joe Biden in emphasizing the need...

Trudeau government set to apologize to Italian Canadians for war internment

May 27, 2021

May 27, 2021

It is a stretch of road lined with postcard perfect views and promises of escape and a sense of...

The West Block — Episode 35, Season 10 – National

May 23, 2021

May 23, 2021

THE WEST BLOCK Episode 35, Season 10 Sunday, May 23, 2021 Host: Mercedes Stephenson Guests: Dominic LeBlanc, Intergovernmental Affairs...

Key takeaways from the U.S. Senate’s report on the ‘absolutely brutal’ Capitol riot – National

June 8, 2021

June 8, 2021

A Senate report examining the security failures surrounding the Jan. 6 riot at the Capitol says missed intelligence, poor...

Senior military leaders golfing with Vance raises concerns about ‘fairness’ in probes: Freeland – National

June 14, 2021

June 14, 2021

Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland says she understands and sympathizes with concerns being raised about “the possibility of real...

‘Not the way to go’: Trudeau condemns recent fires at Catholic churches

June 30, 2021

June 30, 2021

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau expressed disappointment Wednesday about multiple recent fires at churches across Canada, saying “destroying places of...

Belarus arrest of journalist on Ryanair flight a ‘clear attack on democracy’: Trudeau – National

May 25, 2021

May 25, 2021

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says the forced landing of a Ryanair civilian flight and subsequent arrest of a journalist...

Unused J&J COVID-19 vaccine doses will be given back to the company, Tam says – National

June 15, 2021

June 15, 2021

Canada’s top public health official says more than 300,000 unused doses of Johnson & Johnson’s COVID-19 vaccine will be...

ANALYSIS: Nasal lube, DIY COVID-19 tests and the reality of covering summits in a pandemic – National

June 17, 2021

June 17, 2021

“Ralph Goodale will scrum with reporters at the media centre this afternoon.” Scrum. I couldn’t believe my ears. For...

Quebec nationalism push poses election challenge for Justin Trudeau

May 28, 2021

May 28, 2021

Some 25 years after an independence bid by Quebec almost broke Canada apart, a new push by the province...

Senate passes government budget, net-zero carbon bills before breaking for summer – National

June 30, 2021

June 30, 2021

The Senate has passed a government bill to mandate the country reach net-zero emissions by 2050, doing so hours...

New leaders, new era: Israel, U.S. leaders navigate through uncharted crossroads – National

June 20, 2021

June 20, 2021

Their countries at crossroads, the new leaders of the United States and Israel have inherited a relationship that is...