November 27, 2022

VOA Launches Internal Review of Plagiarism Complaints | Voice of America

Voice of America confirmed Friday that incidents of plagiarism have taken place at the network and that an internal review has been launched into how complaints of wrongdoing are handled.

The review was announced the day after The Washington Post reported that two former employees in VOA’s Africa division had raised complaints of plagiarism and editorial bias with supervisors and VOA’s standards editor that they said were not investigated in a timely manner.

The complaints alleged that a freelance journalist plagiarized content and that, separately, a producer for the television show Our Voices plagiarized parts of some scripts.

VOA has not named those involved in the complaints.

In an email to staff Friday, acting VOA Director Yolanda Lopez said management “regrets recent incidents.”

“An internal review is underway to assess the handling of this matter and to ensure that any future incidents will be dealt with promptly and appropriately,” Lopez said, adding that VOA is committed to ensuring plagiarism does not occur and that any future allegations are “dealt with promptly and appropriately.”

The email to staff included a revised copy of VOA’s policy on plagiarism.

In the case involving the freelance reporter, two articles on the English language website were updated this week to include an editor’s note alerting readers that an earlier version contained material that VOA has determined was plagiarized.

The complaints were raised by then-employees Jason Patinkin, a journalist in VOA’s English to Africa service, and Ayen Bior, a co-host of Our Voices who left VOA last year for a job at NPR.

Patinkin said in a published interview that he resigned from VOA over the network’s handling of his unrelated complaints that VOA was showing pro-Ethiopian government bias in its coverage of the conflict in Tigray.

The Horn of Africa service broadcasts to about 12 million people weekly in the Amharic, Afaan Oromoo and Tigrigna languages.

Steven Springer, VOA’s editor for news standards and best practices, said that the network had taken action on the allegations of plagiarism, and that such cases are rare.

“The fact that both of these incidents were put together in one place, yes, it seems like it’s an avalanche,” Springer said, adding that in almost 11 years in the position, he has “dealt with less than 10 possible cases.”

The former VOA employees mentioned in the Post article both said there had been a delay in VOA management handling the situation or taking action.

Springer said he makes his recommendations as quickly as possible after investigating allegations and reports back to the supervisors involved. But he can make only recommendations on the course of action.

“In the case of the Our Voices program, I felt like I did that very expediently. I feel like I did that within a matter of days,” Springer said. “It was one that when I saw it … my reaction was, ‘OK, I know what this is.’ And I reported back.”

His recommendation was that the scripts flagged did constitute plagiarism and that the supervisor should discuss the issue with those involved.

But according to the Post, the content first flagged by Bior in February 2020 remained online until May 25.

Springer confirmed that three episodes of Our Voices — from December 2018, and June and July 2019 — were removed from VOA’s website this week. A message appears in their place explaining the reason for their removal.

The acting director’s statement Friday did not give specifics about the incidents but said the internal review will assess how they were handled.

With the case of the freelancer, Springer said he had earlier recommended to the person overseeing the journalist’s work that the journalist not be used for radio reports because his “answers weren’t necessarily based on his own reporting. It was based on information he gleaned elsewhere.”

After that, complaints were later raised about the freelancer’s plagiarized content appearing in web articles.

A review of content the freelancer contributed to found two cases of plagiarized content. The freelancer is no longer used by VOA divisions.

Kelly McBride, senior vice president and chair of the Craig Newmark Center for Ethics and Leadership at the Poynter Institute, said having transparent policies on dealing with allegations of plagiarism is good for journalists as well as their audience.

“In most cases, plagiarism harms the journalists. It doesn’t harm the audience most of the time, assuming that the information is accurate and it also hasn’t been fabricated,” McBride said. “But in most cases, you can rectify the situation by adding in proper attribution and links to the original material. And it’s mostly embarrassing for the publication.”

“That solves most of the post-publication problems. I mean, you still have a problem with the individual” she said, adding that “some sort of discipline” is needed to send a message that plagiarism is wrong. 

This story has been updated to clarify Patinkin’s reasons for leaving VOA.

in U.S.
Related Posts

Suspect Arraigned in Killing of American Student in Russia | Voice of America

June 20, 2021

June 20, 2021

MOSCOW – A court in central Russia on Sunday arraigned a suspect on murder charges in the death of an...

New Statue of Liberty Arrives in New York From France | Voice of America

June 30, 2021

June 30, 2021

A new, smaller version of the Statue of Liberty arrived Wednesday at Ellis Island in New York Harbor, a gift...

Biden to Reassure Allies of US Commitment to NATO Mutual Defense Clause | Voice of America

June 13, 2021

June 13, 2021

BRUSSELS – The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) is set to discuss revising its strategic concept when its leaders, including...

Biden Aims to Vaccinate 70% of US Adults by July 4 | Voice of America

June 3, 2021

June 3, 2021

President Joe Biden is launching a monthlong nationwide push to get 70% of American adults vaccinated by Independence Day on...

Thousands of Children Separated from Parents Under Trump’s Zero-Tolerance Policy ID’d | Voice of America

June 8, 2021

June 8, 2021

The Biden administration has identified more than 3,900 children who were separated from their parents at the U.S.-Mexico border under...

Former US Ambassador Bill Richardson Heads to Myanmar

November 1, 2021

November 1, 2021

Former U.S. ambassador and former New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson is heading to Myanmar on a private humanitarian mission that...

Biden, Western Governors to Discuss Wildfire Response | Voice of America

June 30, 2021

June 30, 2021

U.S. President Joe Biden is holding talks Wednesday with a group of governors from eight Western states about wildfire preparedness...

Howard University Names College of Fine Arts for Chadwick Boseman | Voice of America

May 27, 2021

May 27, 2021

WASHINGTON – While studying at Howard University, young Chadwick Boseman helped lead a student protest against plans to merge his...

Climate-Related Drought Disasters Threaten Development, UN Warns | Voice of America

June 17, 2021

June 17, 2021

GENEVA – The United Nations warns accelerating climate change is causing a dramatic intensification of global drought disasters, which are...

Biden Honors Tulsa Race Massacre Victims | Voice of America

June 1, 2021

June 1, 2021

President Joe Biden is in Tulsa, Oklahoma Tuesday, the 100th anniversary of the 1921 massacre that decimated a Black community....

US to Offer Alternative to China’s Belt and Road Initiative | Voice of America

June 12, 2021

June 12, 2021

PLYMOUTH, ENGLAND – U.S. President Joe Biden’s administration said it will announce an infrastructure financing mechanism for low- and middle-income...

At Tulsa Centennial, Biden Unveils Steps to Narrow Racial Wealth Gap | Voice of America

June 2, 2021

June 2, 2021

On Tuesday, Joe Biden became the first sitting American president to commemorate the anniversary of the destruction of a prosperous...

Americans Ramp Up Travel During Memorial Day Weekend | Voice of America

May 29, 2021

May 29, 2021

Americans are celebrating the start of the Memorial Day weekend by hitting the roads and skies as they seek to...

Biden Budget to Propose $6 Trillion in 2022 Spending | Voice of America

May 28, 2021

May 28, 2021

U.S. President Joe Biden on Friday will ask Congress for the authority to spend nearly $6 trillion in 2022, which...

Billionaire Blast Off: Richard Branson Plans Space Trip Ahead of Rival Bezos | Voice of America

July 2, 2021

July 2, 2021

WASHINGTON – Call it a space race for billionaires: British mogul Richard Branson one-upped rival Jeff Bezos on Thursday, announcing...