December 6, 2022

Why Crime Could Kill Crypto

The strongest argument against cryptocurrencies used to be that they had yet to show they were much good for anything. Now the strongest argument against them may be that they have become far too good at one thing: enabling crime.

Not long after the first of the private digital currencies, bitcoin, launched in 2009, crooks recognized its appeal. While law enforcement is proving increasingly adept at tracking bitcoin transactions and at times seizing ill-gotten money, the ability to make digital payments without financial intermediaries has facilitated activities such as the selling of illegal goods and services online and money laundering. In a 2019 paper, researchers Sean Foley, Jonathan Karlsen and Tālis Putniņš estimated that 46% of bitcoin transactions conducted between January 2009 and April 2017 were for illegal activity.

Speculative trading has since taken up an ever rising share of transactions, but a spate of recent ransomware attacks, where cybercriminals lock up a victim network’s files and demand payment for their release, most often in bitcoin, has raised the threat level on digital currencies’ crime problem. An attack last month on Colonial Pipeline Co. shut down a critical East Coast gasoline pipeline; another, on

JBS SA,

halted operations earlier this month at some of the largest meat plants in the U.S.

More than just money is at stake. When organizations such as hospitals are attacked, lives can be on the line. In a recent interview with The Wall Street Journal, Federal Bureau of Investigation Director

Christopher Wray

compared the difficulties posed by the recent spate of ransomware with the challenge posed by the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.

One problem for law enforcement is that, even when the cybercriminals behind them can be identified, thefts that once would have required exchanges of bags of money or suitcases of gold to pull off can now happen entirely in countries where the U.S. has no extradition treaty. The FBI was able to seize a portion of cryptocurrency that Colonial Pipeline paid to ransomware gang DarkSide but, because the gang is believed to operate in Russia, its members might be beyond reach.

Another is that there is no easy way to beef up digital security to the point that hackers can simply be kept out of data vaults; the information protection systems we rely upon are too complex, and too pockmarked with vulnerabilities, for that.

Making it harder for cybercriminals to receive cryptocurrency payments, and thereby reducing the financial incentives for ransomware attacks, might help. Here, Mr. Wray’s comparison with Sept. 11 is telling. Following the attacks, the 2001 Patriot Act introduced an array of tougher provisions to the 1970 Bank Secrecy Act aimed at disrupting the financing of terror networks.

A blunt way to stem the problem would be to widely ban payment or trading in cryptocurrencies, as authorities in China have sought to do. But given the now-substantial financial stakes in them—cryptocurrencies have a combined value of $1.6 trillion, according to coinmarketcap.com—it is hard to imagine there being the U.S. political will to do that. At least not as a first step.

But there are other steps U.S. authorities could take, and these might also diminish the viability of the use of crypto in commerce, or at least raise the cost of using it.

One approach might be to make it harder to use or transfer cryptocurrency once stolen, much like suitcases filled with $1 million in cash are difficult to actually spend without getting noticed. The Biden administration is proposing to adopt the same requirement for crypto that all businesses have when they are paid more than $10,000 in cash—reporting it to the Internal Revenue Service.

Ransomware attacks are increasing in frequency, victim losses are skyrocketing, and hackers are shifting their targets. WSJ’s Dustin Volz explains why these attacks are on the rise and what the U.S. can do to fight them. Photo illustration: Laura Kammermann

Governments also could ratchet up monitoring responsibilities. A number of measures are already under consideration. Citing in part “national security imperatives,” the U.S. Treasury Department last year proposed additional vetting for cryptocurrency transfers to so-called “unhosted wallets” that aren’t associated with a bank or other regulated financial intermediary. The Financial Action Task Force, a global standard-setter for combating money-laundering, recently proposed new guidelines for expanding security requirements to a much wider range of crypto entities.

Such measures could make a segment of crypto transactions even beyond bitcoin a little less anonymous and decentralized—a prospect that many advocates would be loath to see. Increased regulations could also make legitimate transactions more onerous, reducing cryptocurrencies’ appeal.

But the biggest risk to cryptocurrencies may be that such regulatory efforts won’t be effective in curtailing the dangerous acts cryptocurrencies have helped enable.

In that case, the crimes might only become more heinous and severe restrictions on the use of cryptocurrencies more politically palatable.

Write to Justin Lahart at [email protected] and Telis Demos at [email protected]

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

in Tech
Related Posts

Amazon and Apple Built Vast Wireless Networks Using Your Devices. Here’s How They Work.

May 7, 2021

May 7, 2021

What to do if you’re a globe-spanning tech titan that wants to connect millions or even billions of devices, but...

American Airlines Invests in Electric Flying Taxis

June 10, 2021

June 10, 2021

The airline plans to invest $25 million in Vertical Aerospace Group Ltd., a U.K.-based electric aircraft startup. The world’s largest...

Ransomware Attack Roiled Meat Giant JBS, Then Spilled Over to Farmers and Restaurants

June 11, 2021

June 11, 2021

Employees at the U.S. division of JBS SA, the world’s largest meat company, noticed something wrong in their computer systems...

App Taps Unwitting Users Abroad to Gather Open-Source Intelligence

June 24, 2021

June 24, 2021

WASHINGTON—A consumer app has assembled a workforce of hundreds of thousands of smartphone users world-wide, some of whom are being...

China Evergrande Scrapes Together More Cash From Tech Company Stake Sale

November 9, 2021

November 9, 2021

SINGAPORE— China Evergrande Group raised around $145 million in recent days by selling a chunk of its shares in a...

Samsung to Choose Taylor, Texas, for $17 Billion Chip-Making Factory

November 23, 2021

November 23, 2021

Samsung Electronics Co. plans to build a roughly $17 billion chip-making plant in Taylor, Texas, according to people familiar with...

Microsoft Plans to Pull the Plug on Internet Explorer

May 20, 2021

May 20, 2021

Microsoft Corp. MSFT -0.53% said it plans to largely retire its Internet Explorer browser, adding to the digital scrap heap...

Next-Generation GPS Firm NextNav Nears SPAC Deal to Go Public

June 10, 2021

June 10, 2021

NextNav Holdings LLC is nearing a combination with a special-purpose acquisition company that would take the next-generation GPS firm public...

Bitcoin Price Slips on Elon Musk’s Breakup Meme Tweet

June 4, 2021

June 4, 2021

Bitcoin, dogecoin and other cryptocurrencies skidded Friday, extending their monthlong rout, following another cryptic tweet from Elon Musk. Bitcoin was...

DraftKings Shares Fall After Hindenburg Unveils Short Position

June 15, 2021

June 15, 2021

Shares of DraftKings Inc. DKNG -4.17% slid as much as 12% on Tuesday after short seller Hindenburg Research said that...

New York City Law Department Hit by Cyberattack

June 8, 2021

June 8, 2021

Hackers breached the New York City Law Department’s computer system over the weekend, prompting the city to limit access to...

Ransomware Group Behind Meat-Supply Attack Threatens Hundreds of New Targets

July 3, 2021

July 3, 2021

The ransomware group that collected an $11 million payment from meat producer JBS SA about a month ago has begun...

Japan’s In-Home Robot Experiment Short Circuits

June 29, 2021

June 29, 2021

TOKYO—Japan’s humanoid robots are struggling to find homes. SoftBank Group Corp.’s robotics unit said Tuesday it stopped manufacturing a humanlike...

Driver-Assistance Crashes Attract Closer U.S. Scrutiny

June 29, 2021

June 29, 2021

Federal regulators are tightening their oversight of car crashes that involve advanced driver-assistance or automated-driving features, a shift that follows...

Pinterest Vows to Add More Female Executives, Workers of Color

May 18, 2021

May 18, 2021

Pinterest Inc. PINS 0.77% has set new targets for increasing the number of women in leadership and improving racial and...