December 8, 2022

Why Doing Good Is No Longer Bad Business

It seems the modern corporate mission statement could use an update: Do well by doing good—or else.

Earning the perception of good corporate citizenship, in the form of environmental, social and governance bona fides, is no longer optional for the modern executive. That point was driven home last month as Exxon Mobil shareholders elected two directors nominated by an upstart activist hedge fund unhappy with the oil giant’s climate policies. A third director is likely to win election, the company said Wednesday. The activist’s victory was especially jarring because it owns a tiny fraction of Exxon stock and Chief Executive Officer

Darren Woods

had campaigned personally against the movement.

The vote marks a high point of sorts for the multiyear ESG movement, a framework that calls for investors to consider a company’s overall impact on the world beyond its financial returns. The trend shows no signs of slowing down. There have been 610 news releases mentioning environmental, social and governance principles from current S&P 500 members so far this year through May, according to data from financial research firm Sentieo. That is more than double the rate of the same period last year.

Investors care a great deal about ESG harmony when stock prices are high and times for big business are good, and boy are they good. Interest rates have hardly ever been lower and corporate tax rates are still favorable. Government policies on key issues such as antitrust have been permissive. A Wall Street Journal analysis found that median pay for the chief executives of more than 300 of the biggest U.S. public companies reached $13.7 million last year, up from $12.8 million for the same companies a year earlier. The onset of a global pandemic and subsequent recession left many of the largest companies and their bosses in an even stronger position. But a turn in the stock market’s fortunes could slow the ESG craze on Wall Street.

As for consumers, they are bound to focus less on issues such as clean energy if, say, traditional fuel sources become more scarce. Don’t expect motorists to appreciate a feel-good origin story for gasoline that costs eight bucks a gallon.

The socially-minded aspirations of big corporations and their executives seem performative to their critics and, to a not-insignificant share of the public, veer into partisan politics. But in this environment, such behavior in the C Suite is entirely rational. There is real demand for good feelings among consumers and investors.

“We’re not hungry for a cause. We’re starved for a cause,” entrepreneur and former hedge-fund manager Vivek Ramaswamy told me. Mr. Ramaswamy, the chairman of Roivant Sciences and the author of “Woke, Inc.: Inside Corporate America’s Social Justice Scam,” argues that declining membership in organized religion and waning faith in public institutions create a void that businesses can help fill. “The value of a product used to be based on how well it functions—now it includes its origin story,” he says. Tesla CEO

Elon Musk’s

popularity in some circles, for instance, is tied to his persona as a maverick executive fighting climate change.

The structure of modern Wall Street feeds demand as well. The rise of strategies such as indexing mean that large asset managers are more powerful than ever. They also have to worry about their image, because funds with an ESG mandate are attracting money from investors and often command higher fees than other offerings. What is more, large fund managers often follow the recommendations of shareholder advisory services when voting in a proxy contest. As a practical matter, winning the vote of millions of shares can require convincing just a few key individuals of a proposal’s merit.

Share Your Thoughts

How will the next downturn affect the push for environmental, social and governance changes at America’s corporations? Join the conversation below.

This leads to a simple question for executives. “Do you want your company’s stock to have inflows?” Nick Mazing, director of research at Sentieo, asks rhetorically. Not being in the club can be costly: Even before the Exxon campaign, so-called vice stocks such as tobacco companies and fossil fuel producers have been relative laggards compared with those of businesses perceived to be environmentally friendly.

Don’t expect this state of affairs to change soon. Large pension funds and other Wall Street kingmakers have signed the United Nations-backed Principles for Responsible Investment, a document from 2006 that calls for investors to weigh ESG principles in making investment decisions. Those who sign on may well have an easier time accessing capital than those who don’t. Companies have begun issuing debt with special rules that tie interest rates to whether the issuers meet self-made targets for goals such as cutting carbon emissions or for naming more women to corporate boards.

The shocking turnabout at Exxon offers other companies a warning about what the future holds. About a decade ago, oil executives would publicly play down the environmental impact of an oil spill. Now, a descendant of Standard Oil itself must give climate activists a say in its corporate strategy.

“You might not be interested in ESG, but ESG is interested in you,” says Mr. Mazing.

Copyright ©2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

Related Posts

Latin America Leads Revolt Against Free-Market Growth Model

June 2, 2021

June 2, 2021

Latin America, which led the developing world in adopting the market-friendly model of economic development, may now be leading the...

Commodity Price Surges Add to Inflation Fears

June 7, 2021

June 7, 2021

The run-up in commodity prices is casting a cloud over the global economic recovery, slamming vulnerable businesses and households and...

U.S. Fight Against Chinese 5G Efforts Shifts From Threats to Incentives

June 14, 2021

June 14, 2021

The U.S. government is ratcheting up pressure on Beijing’s 5G ambitions overseas, offering financial incentives and other enticements to countries...

U.S. to Downgrade Mexico’s Air-Safety Rating

May 22, 2021

May 22, 2021

U.S. officials are planning to downgrade Mexico’s aviation-safety rating in coming days, people familiar with the matter said, complicating a...

Biden, Republican Senator to Discuss Revised Infrastructure Proposal

June 4, 2021

June 4, 2021

WASHINGTON—President Biden was set on Friday to speak with a Senate Republican leading efforts to reach a compromise on infrastructure...

Fed’s Harker Supports Start of Bond Buying Pullback Later This Year

July 1, 2021

July 1, 2021

Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia President Patrick Harker said Thursday that while an interest rate rise lies some ways in...

Can America’s Solar Power Industry Compete with China’s? One Firm Tries.

June 21, 2021

June 21, 2021

WALBRIDGE, Ohio—Solar panels are part of any formula for fighting climate change, yet the U.S. makes few of them, since...

Small Business Needed Federal Help. The Agency in Charge Fell Short.

June 17, 2021

June 17, 2021

In the pandemic shutdown last year, three-quarters of the nation’s small employers turned to the Small Business Administration for help....

NY Fed May Consumer Survey Finds Public Bracing for Large Inflation Gains

June 14, 2021

June 14, 2021

Americans are bracing for a wave of higher inflation over the next year, amid projections of big increases in home...

Ryanair CEO Calls Belarus Flight Diversion a ‘Premeditated Hijacking’

May 27, 2021

May 27, 2021

Ryanair Holdings PLC rejected Belarus’s account of the diversion of one of its planes Sunday, angrily condemning the forced landing...

Goat Group, Parent of Sneaker Marketplace, Valued at $3.7 Billion in Latest Funding Round

June 24, 2021

June 24, 2021

Goat Group, parent company of an online marketplace for sneakerheads, said it has raised $195 million through private investors to...

Democrats Focus on Turning Tax Talk Into Action

June 27, 2021

June 27, 2021

WASHINGTON—Democrats face a daunting task: turning years of talking about raising taxes on corporations and high-income Americans into legislation that...

China Evergrande Scrapes Together More Cash From Tech Company Stake Sale

November 9, 2021

November 9, 2021

SINGAPORE— China Evergrande Group raised around $145 million in recent days by selling a chunk of its shares in a...

PE-Backed Hospital Chain Got Help From Major Landlord as Losses Mounted

June 18, 2021

June 18, 2021

Medical Properties Trust Inc. MPW -4.89% is a little-known real-estate investor that helps private-equity firms cash in on their hospital...

Amazon Faces Possible $425 Million EU Privacy Fine

June 10, 2021

June 10, 2021

A European Union privacy regulator has proposed a fine of more than $425 million against Amazon.com Inc., part of a...