May 19, 2022

YouTube wins user copyright fight in top EU court ruling, Europe News & Top Stories

LUXEMBOURG (REUTERS) – Google’s YouTube won its latest copyright-infringement challenge after Europe’s top court said online platforms are not liable for users uploading unauthorised works unless the platforms failed to take quick action to remove or block access to the content.

The case marks the latest development in a long-running battle between Europe’s US$1 trillion (S$1.35 trillion) creative industry and online platforms, with the former seeking redress for unauthorised works that are uploaded.

It is also part of the wider debate on how much online platforms and social media should do to police the posting of unauthorised, illegal or hateful content, an issue that European Union regulators are targeting with tough new rules that could come into force next year.

“As currently stands, operators of online platforms do not, in principle, themselves make a communication to the public of copyright-protected content illegally posted online by users of those platforms,” the EU Court of Justice (CJEU) said.

“However, those operators do make such a communication in breach of copyright where they contribute, beyond merely making those platforms available, to giving access to such content to the public,” judges said.

The EU court said platforms could also be liable if they do not put in place the appropriate technological tools to tackle copyright breaches by their users or where they provide tools on their platforms for illegal sharing of content.

In response to the court ruling a YouTube spokesman said: “YouTube is a leader in copyright and supports rights holders being paid their fair share.

“That’s why we’ve invested in state-of-the-art copyright tools which have created an entirely new revenue stream for the industry. In the past 12 months alone, we have paid US$4 billion to the music industry, over 30 per cent of which comes from monetised user generated content.”

The case underlines a long-running debate on the responsibilities of online platforms, with the CJEU giving useful guidance to national courts assessing such disagreements, said Mr Nils Rauer, a partner at law firm Pinsent Masons.

“The core question is and remains whether the platform is in a rather passive role (no liability) or in an active role (liability). There is a fine line between those two roles,” he said.

“With today’s ruling, the domestic courts will be able to build on more guidance from Luxembourg where to draw the line between the good ones (platforms) and the bad ones,” he said.

YouTube found itself in the dock after Mr Frank Peterson, a music producer, sued the company and Google in Germany over the uploading to YouTube by users in 2008 of several phonograms to which he holds the rights.

In a second case, publishing group Elsevier took legal action against file-hosting service Cyando in Germany after its users uploaded several Elsevier works on its platform Uploaded in 2013 without its approval.

A German court subsequently sought advice from the EU Court of Justice, which ruled on both cases on Tuesday (June 22).

Existing EU rules exempt YouTube and its peers from such liability regarding copyright when they are told of violations and remove them.

The EU last year overhauled its copyright rules for the first time in two decades to help its creative industries by adopting a key provision known as Article 17. This requires YouTube, Facebook’s Instagram and other sharing platforms to install filters to prevent users from uploading copyrighted materials.

But this has drawn criticism from civil rights groups worried about potential censorship by authoritarian governments and risks to freedom of expression.

Several EU countries have yet to transpose the EU law into national legislation, due in part to the Covid-19 pandemic.

The European Commission has also proposed much a more wide-ranging Digital Services Act, which sets stringent obligations on very large online companies, online platforms and hosting services, backed by fines up to 6 per cent of a company’s revenue for non-compliance.

This would apply to websites, Internet infrastructure services and online platforms such as online marketplaces, social networks, content-sharing platforms, app stores, and online travel and accommodation platforms.

The draft rules need to be thrashed out with EU countries and EU lawmakers before they can become law, likely to be next year.

in World
Related Posts

WHO chief says UN body setting up hub to make Covid-19 vaccines in SAfrica, World News & Top Stories

June 21, 2021

June 21, 2021

GENEVA (REUTERS) – The World Health Organization (WHO) is setting up a technology transfer hub for producing mRNA Covid-19 vaccines...

Italy cable car crash probed as child fights for life, Europe News & Top Stories

May 24, 2021

May 24, 2021

STRESA, ITALY (AFP) – Investigators probed the causes of Sunday’s (May 23) terrifying cable car crash in the Italian mountains...

In New York, buildings rise with sections that seem to hover in midair, United States News & Top Stories

June 6, 2021

June 6, 2021

NEW YORK – Ask a child to draw a picture of a skyscraper and he or she will probably sketch...

Egypt intelligence chief expected in occupied Palestinian territories after Israel-Gaza truce, Middle East News & Top Stories

May 30, 2021

May 30, 2021

RAMALLAH, PALESTINIAN TERRITORIES (AFP) – Egypt’s intelligence chief Abbas Kamel was expected in the occupied Palestinian territories Sunday (May 30),...

World in dangerous period, warns WHO as Delta Covid-19 variant evolves, Europe News & Top Stories

July 3, 2021

July 3, 2021

GENEVA – The World Health Organisation (WHO) has warned that the world is in “a very dangerous period” of the coronavirus...

Microsoft says group behind SolarWinds hack now targeting government agencies, NGOs, World News & Top Stories

May 28, 2021

May 28, 2021

WASHINGTON (REUTERS) – The group behind the SolarWinds cyber attack identified late last year is now targeting government agencies, think...

WHO switches to Greek alphabet for coronavirus variant names, Europe News & Top Stories

May 31, 2021

May 31, 2021

GENEVA (AFP) – Covid-19 variants are to be known by letters of the Greek alphabet to avoid stigmatising nations where...

Biden backs taking sexual assault prosecutions away from US military commanders, United States News & Top Stories

July 2, 2021

July 2, 2021

WASHINGTON (REUTERS) – President Joe Biden on Friday (July 2) backed a recommendation that US military prosecutions of sexual assaults...

Retro milk float brings Londoners zero-plastic groceries, Europe News & Top Stories

May 29, 2021

May 29, 2021

LONDON (AFP) – Ella Shone’s small electric truck used to deliver milk but now she drives it around London, selling...

EU to kick off coronavirus pandemic plan with 10 bln euro bond issue: French minister, Europe News & Top Stories

May 31, 2021

May 31, 2021

PARIS (REUTERS) – The European Union plans to kick off its 750 billion euro (S$1.211 trillion) pandemic recovery package with...

Mexico says Covid-19 has affected a fourth of its population, World News & Top Stories

June 12, 2021

June 12, 2021

MEXICO CITY (REUTERS) – About a quarter of Mexico’s 126 million people are estimated to have been infected with the...

EU-approved Covid-19 vaccines protect against Delta variant, says official, Europe News & Top Stories

July 1, 2021

July 1, 2021

BRUSSELS (REUTERS) – Europe’s drug regulator said on Thursday (July 1) that the Covid-19 vaccines approved in the European Union...

Moscow court considers ‘extremism’ label for Navalny group, World News & Top Stories

June 9, 2021

June 9, 2021

MOSCOW (AFP) – A court in Moscow was considering Wednesday (June 9) whether to brand jailed Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny’s...

Three ‘beloved’ snow leopards died of Covid-19 complications at Nebraska Zoo, United States News & Top Stories

November 14, 2021

November 14, 2021

LINCOLN, NEBRASKA (NYTIMES) – Three snow leopards died of complications related to Covid-19 at a zoo in Lincoln, Nebraska, despite...

Pope kisses tattoo number on Auschwitz survivor’s arm, Europe News & Top Stories

May 26, 2021

May 26, 2021

VATICAN CITY (REUTERS) – Pope Francis kissed the number tattooed on the arm of a survivor of medical experiments at...